Ignore the Anti-Learning Brigade.
“You can’t learn art.”
Have you ever heard that?
“You’re just born with it.”
Or that?
“Oh, that looks just awesome, don’t change a thing! It’s perfect.”
How about that?
People that say that are poison. I call them the Anti-Learning Brigade. The snobby intellectual \ artsy elite. They’ll play both angles… tell you that it’s impossible to learn to do what you’re trying to do, or that you can’t or shouldn’t try to get better at it.
Why? To grant themselves a false and unearned sense of superiority, and to cut off your legs so you can’t compete. They may not realize they’re doing it — I’ve seen plenty of examples of that — but the result is the same.
The reason I dismiss them is because of this simple question:
What does “You can’t learn it” offer to help people that want to learn it?
That’s not knowledge. That’s not wisdom. That’s not any kind of help. That’s ANTI-KNOWLEDGE. That’s the most destructive, least constructive, most useless piece of advice that can be imparted to another that’s trying to learn.
“Stop trying. Stop putting forth the effort. You’ll never do it. No one can do it… except me, I was born with it. Some people have just been born with the skill and have done it all their life. How could you possibly compete with that? It’s inborn, a gift, not something that can be trained. Just give up. Don’t try. You’re wasting your time.”
I’ve made my life and career out of ignoring people like that, to my great benefit. I’m past the point of thinking anything they say holds weight, but when I see them telling eager young kids that are just starting out that they’ll never be good and can’t learn, I get angry.
Very angry.
Because if I’d listened to them when I was at that stage, I’d be nowhere. I think about where I was then, and where I am now, and I imagine everything I learned and everything I became in that time DYING. All that existence unravelling, just because someone was insecure and trying to hold me down.
By what right can one human tell another that his efforts will never matter? That his hard work will amount to nothing? That he’d be BETTER if he GAVE UP and STOPPED TRYING?
Never listen to these people. Ignore them. Cut them out of your life. Treat what they say as a challenge to try harder, get better and improve. “Can’t learn it, eh? Watch me crush you.” It does happen. People can make themselves out of nothing. You can learn anything. You can get better at anything.
You don’t even need to start out being smart! You just need to be willing to learn and have the determination to BECOME smart. If you’re persistent enough, never give up, keep trying and constantly adapt to new ideas and throw out your favorite old ones, you can do absolutely ANYTHING.
If no one could learn anything, no one could DO anything. And look around you. See how the world works. Cars move, airplanes fly, skyscrapers are erected, electricity flows, computer systems whirr happily, and the gears of the world go on grinding. If no one can learn anything, how does any of that work? I haven’t seen many infants assembling airplanes lately.
Explain that, Anti-Learning Brigade.
Similar Posts:
August 30th, 2006 at 8:05 pm
Spot on Jon. I just made a big moderation post on an art forum about this EXACTLY. The first reply to a work in progress was “perfect! gj!”, and it made me angry too! Go get ‘em.
August 31st, 2006 at 5:01 am
Well said! I totally agree. I find my self telling my little cousin things like this, nothing harsh though. I don’t find him as any type of threat, even hope to work with him some day.
Just that he has his mind on making an online donkey kong game ;) Tell him somethings I regret later (though I tell him we have to be realistic. Can’t make the game in two weeks) and let him know that I will help whenever needed. We end up learning together.
August 31st, 2006 at 11:34 am
http://www.wattsatelier.com/home.html
Oh God. You guys are getting so deluded with yourselves it’s ridiculus. Until you can draw at least at that ability, don’t get so cocky.
The drums are beating. Sooner or later the game industry is going to demand ability…..not kissing up.
If you think you guys are hardcore……you should listen to the instructors I listen to.
August 31st, 2006 at 11:56 am
ftp://ftp1.highmoonstudios.com/GDCwebisodes/after_hours.wmv
You wanna see hardcore….that’s hardcore. I have to compete with 200 pound gorillas.
Dave Wilkins drew the Zombo graphic novel.
I got to compete with graduates from Art Center.
Boom ba ba boom ba ba boom….the drums are beating……..
September 1st, 2006 at 4:36 pm
NoSeRider, I am not sure what you are upset about, but Jon’s post was mainly about people who say things like “You just have to be born with the talent”, which implies that a person can’t train him/herself to get talented. It’s a very empowering thing to know that just because you don’t know how now, it doesn’t mean you will never know.
It’s the point of the Thousander Club. Chess masters aren’t born as chess masters. They train for thousands of hours over their lifetimes. Experts are experts because they spend thousands of hours with their expertise, not because of some ingrain talent.
Again, it’s empowering. I know that I could eventually compete with those 200 pound gorillas myself if I would dedicate my time to learning how to compete. I’ve spent many hours programming in the past year, and I’ve gone from being as good as some beginner to actually being fairly familiar with the C++ programming language. I still have a ways to go, but I know that last year I wouldn’t be able to talk about the language or programming concepts nearly as well I can now. I am much more comfortable talking to experts, and it’s all because I put in the time.
Am I full of myself for thinking in this way, too?
September 2nd, 2006 at 8:02 am
[quote]NoSeRider, I am not sure what you are upset about, but Jon’s post was mainly about people who say things like “You just have to be born with the talent”[/quote]
No. I’m basically agreeing with Jon.
My experiences are the game industry hires people based on networking ability….how you present ‘yourself’. As long as ‘charm’ prevails over artistic ability, I think that ‘you have to be born with it’ attitude is going to prevail.
That’s where that deluded thing comes in……are you truly an artist if your art suffers at the expense of ‘ego’?
It’s not a ‘you have to be born with it’….but you have to be open to it. You have to think outside of yourself.
Jason Manley from Massive Black is very underwhelmed by what is churning out from art schools…..so it’s not some elitist attitude. People are failing to see art as a discipline.
Being an artist isn’t about crushing people. It’s about communicating something that could inspire……you can’t do that if your art sucks.
Some of the best artists I’ve known have been humble….those are the ones that inspire, because they put their art ahead of themselves.
I’m not certain you can be humble in the game industry?
September 2nd, 2006 at 8:40 am
Jason Manley is the biggest douche bag I’ve ever met, and unfortunately 95% of people that say they don’t want to hear ‘gj!’ are exactly the same that get upset when they get anything *but* ‘gj’, which is exactly why most people don’t bother beyond ‘gj’.
Oh, btw — gj on those posts.
September 5th, 2006 at 6:22 pm
Lovely Rant. I wrote one almost exactly the same one day about Math. I wholeheartedly agree with you here.
September 6th, 2006 at 6:07 pm
Thanks for the comments, guys! Sorry, been on a brief vacation.
Chris, awesome! That’s exactly the kind of thing I’m talking about.
radioact1ve, well, I mean… yeah, online Donkey Kong game. There are some lines one simply does not cross. ;)
GBGames, hey man! Good to hear from ya. :) I had only heard about the Thousander Club in passing, but that’s an extremely cool idea. Had I some sort of specific project, I’d definitely join. I’m going to pass that one around to my friends!
NoSeRider: You raise an interesting point, about not being certain if you can be humble in the game industry. I think you most definitely can… it’s just easier to be extremely brash, bold and arrogant to make an impression than it is to be a total humble badass. At some point, yeah, you have to amplify the ego and make yourself heard, but I don’t think it’s necessarily a choice between EITHER talent OR superego. Or maybe the public forum for the superego isn’t where the humble people ever need really aim to be… they just sit behind the scenes, cranking away and kicking ass without needing to be highly visible pompous assholes. :)
JM, hahaha, you are correct. Ultimately all people want is to feel important. Most people are happy to get whatever basic validation they can get, and a few actually care about getting better and better and really want to push forward and improve. And thanks. :)
Christopher, awesome! Thanks man, I really appreciate that. Is your rant online anywhere, by any chance? Would love to give it a read.
October 3rd, 2006 at 7:35 am
Art can totally be learned. I agree with the comment Jason Manley had previously about art schools not doing a great job nowadays. And BTW, Manley has done more for art and artists than just about any young artist alive right now. ConceptArt.org is a an amazing achievement and Massive Black needs no defending.
Shauna “Tina” Peterson
Laguna Beach, CA
October 4th, 2006 at 3:10 pm
I agree there, ConceptArt.org is fantastic and I’ve seen nothing but incredible work come out of Massive Black. I found my concept artist for Dungeon Runners on CA after weeks of searching, in fact.
October 10th, 2006 at 12:19 pm
Ateliers are gonna kick your ass…….Jason Manley supports them.